To get the straight story, sometimes you need to ask everyone involved. PwC’s 2023 Global CEO Survey contained some findings about company cultures that I found alarming. Just 56% of CEOs said that leaders in their company encourage dissent and debate. Only 46% said that leaders in the company tolerate small-scale failures. That’s concerning, but it turns out that employees think the problem is actually worse. In PwC’s 2023 Global Workforce Hopes and Fears Survey, only 33% of employees said that their manager encourages dissent and debate, and just 35% said that their manager tolerates small-scale failures.
If there’s a bright spot in the data for me, it’s that CEOs and employees agree on one thing: there is an urgent need to reinvent. In fact, for many companies, their very survival depends on it. Among CEOs, 39% say that their organisation will not survive 10 years on its current path, and the number is nearly as high among employees (33%).
I believe that large change programs can succeed only with a workforce that’s empowered to take risks, speak up and directly engage in the process. Get that right, and your reinvention program stands a much better chance of hitting its goals. Get that wrong—and our data suggests many companies are—and your employees will simply go through the motions and tell you what they think you want to hear. People tend to adopt what they have helped to create, so if you involve your employees in the transformation, they will feel ownership and help drive the change required.
How to do better? I think companies can improve their culture and become more reinvention-ready only if leaders and managers apply a humanistic approach to engaging with the workforce. This is one of the key characteristics of a transformative leader.
Businesses face an existential threat from disruptive change. To respond, they need to reinvent, which requires that they put the right culture in place for everyone to contribute. Many CEOs think they have this kind of culture in place, but, as our data shows, that may be optimistic. The smart ones will take steps to ensure that they really do.