The short answer is: It depends on the extent to which the requirements of each purpose align in terms of the basis of value, applicable standard, valuation date and the depth of the documentation.
Each valuation report is prepared for a specific purpose set out in the engagement letter, e.g. a transaction, financial reporting, legal dispute, tax planning or regulatory requirement. The purpose of the valuation defines the basis of value (market value, fair value under IFRS 13, investment value, liquidation value) and sometimes even the findings since different value bases may produce different numbers for the same asset.
When it is possible
If two purposes require the same bases of value, the same valuation date and compatible documentation requirements, then one report may serve both needs. For example, estimation of the fair value of a business under IFRS 13 for financial reporting and supporting the price to the supervisory board are often compatible tasks.
When it is impossible or risky
Valuation for a sale/purchase transaction and valuation for tax purposes may require different bases of value, different assumptions and different levels of support. A report prepared for the purpose of negotiating with an investor may not meet procedural requirements of a court or arbitration. Relying on a report outside of the defined purpose gives rise to risks both for the client and for the valuer and is contrary to the requirements of IVS in terms of clear definition of the purpose and restrictions on use of the report.
What we recommend
If you expect that you will need the valuation findings for multiple purposes, let us know at the planning stage. This will help us design the scope in such a way that one project can cover as many needs as possible, i.e. to align the basis of value, to consider the needs of all stakeholders and to prepare additional materials, as appropriate, such as a separate opinion or an adapted version of the report for a different user.
This approach is more effective than requesting separate valuations for each purpose, both in terms of the budget and in terms of the consistent findings.
Expecting to use valuation for multiple purposes? Discuss it with our team at the planning state and we will help identify the right scope of work.