{{item.title}}
As tax practitioners, we are quite used to encountering transactions with non-resident foreign corporations (NRFCs). We regularly assist corporate clients, both foreign and local, in securing tax rulings or treaty relief confirmations from the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) to avail of tax exemption or preferential tax rates under the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, (the Tax Code) or applicable tax treaties.
Discussions about lower tax rates and tax exemption almost always end on a positive note from taxpayers (quite unlike conversations involving tax investigations). A recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) decision did exactly that (CTA Case Nos. 10710, 10878, and 11065). The case involved dividends paid by a Philippine corporation to its Dutch parent company. The dividends were initially subjected to a 10% final withholding tax based on the tax treaty between the Philippines and the Netherlands. However, the Dutch parent company subsequently filed a claim for refund with the BIR, arguing that the taxes withheld from the dividend payments had been erroneously or illegally withheld.
My article focuses on dividends paid to foreign corporations and the unusual circumstances that gave rise to both an exemption and refund.The Dutch parent company, in its petition, cited Section 32(B)(7)(a)(ii) of the Tax Code as the basis for its claim if the BIR failed to act on the refund or denied the refund application. The said provision is more commonly known as the sovereign immunity clause. The parent company posited that it is entitled to the refund based on the grounds that the dividends it received were exempt from withholding tax based on the said provision of the Tax Code, since (1) the dividends constituted income derived from investments in the Philippines by a financing institution owned and controlled by the Kingdom of Norway, a foreign government, and (2) the administrative and judicial claims for refund were filed on a timely basis.
An interesting aspect of the case is the corporate structure involved. The Dutch parent company turned out to be a wholly owned subsidiary of a Norwegian company, which was established by a Norwegian Investment Fund founded by the Norwegian government to finance investments in developing countries. Still following me there?
Before you get lost, let’s quickly revisit the legal basis for the Dutch parent company’s claim for income tax exemption.
Philippine tax law provides that income derived from investments in the Philippines — such as loans, stocks, bonds, or other domestic securities, or interest earned from Philippine bank deposits — shall be exempt from income tax when earned by (i) foreign governments (ii) financing institutions owned, controlled, or enjoying refinancing from foreign governments, and (iii) international or regional financial institutions established by foreign governments.
For the tax exemption to apply, two (2) conditions must be present:
The CTA found that both requisites were satisfied.
Given that the Dutch parent company is wholly owned subsidiary of an entity established and funded by the Norwegian government, it qualified as a financing institution owned, controlled, or enjoying refinancing from a foreign government. Accordingly, the dividend income it received from the Philippine subsidiary fell within the scope of the tax exemption.
The CTA, therefore ruled in favor of the taxpayer and effectively ordered the grant of the tax refund of the taxes withheld and remitted to the BIR.
Seldom do we encounter in practice the tax exemptions on dividend payments to NRFCs. It is worth noting that the exemption is not limited to dividends; it may also apply to certain interest income earned by qualified entities.
Tax refund claims can be quite a challenge, often involving extensive documentation, lengthy administrative proceedings, and, in many cases, litigation before the courts. The process demands not only resources, but also a lot of persistence and patience.
Nevertheless, this CTA decision demonstrates that a refund claim can succeed when supported by a clear legal basis and complete supporting documentation. More importantly, it serves as a reminder that taxpayers should not overlook reliefs that may be available under the Tax Code merely because they are rarely invoked.
As the Ease of Paying Taxes (EOPT) Act and its implementing regulations continue to reshape tax administration, taxpayers remain optimistic that the refund process will become much easier and timely. I hope that one day, tax refund discussions in our country can be viewed in a more positive light. Until then, it would be prudent for taxpayers to carefully assess the tax implications of their transactions and determine the availability of any applicable exemptions, and avoid the time, cost and cash flow impact that comes with filing refund claims.
The views or opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of Isla Lipana & Co. The content is for general information purposes only, and should not be used as a substitute for specific advice.