Pennsylvania - Royalties on intellectual property held not subject to sales and use tax

Start adding items to your reading lists:
Save this item to:
This item has been saved to your reading list.

October 2018


The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled that royalties paid for intellectual property used in conjunction with the operation of games played on video machines are not subject to sales or use tax.

The takeaway

This case may put to rest the Commonwealth’s efforts to systematically extend the definition of ‘tangible personal property’ to transactions traditionally viewed as the sale of an intangible.  The Commonwealth’s endeavor to subject such intangibles to tax by virtue of the transactions being integrated with tangible personal property appears to be put into check by requiring an analysis of whether the payments for the use of the intellectual property are distinct from the purchases of the tangible personal property.  The Court essentially has reinstated a test whereby the nature of the transactions should be examined.

Taxpayers should consider structuring their transactions involving royalty payments for intellectual property in a manner intended to be consistent with this opinion.  It remains to be seen how the Commonwealth interprets this decision with regard to transactions in which both nontaxable and taxable transactions are linked in some fashion (e.g., computer services and sale of software).

Contact us

Peter Michalowski

Peter Michalowski

State and Local Tax Leader, PwC US

Follow us