Innovation disciplines

Two views

Innovation is bounded by two disciplines: market discipline, which governs exploration and leads to substantial innovation, and hierarchical discipline, which exploits prior innovation and moves it forward incrementally. Both are necessary for innovation to occur and endure.

Exploration

Image: Exploration
     

Market discipline

Enables organic emergence of innovation by harnessing creative tensions
 

Hierarchical discipline

Enables incremental innovation by harnessing adaptive tensions
 

Exploitation

Image: Exploitation
 
 
  Resources  
  • Available to anyone with a worthy innovative idea and plan
  • Just enough to reach an important milestone of success or failure
  • Decisions made by a group of people—not by a single manager
 
  • Available through cascading allocation based on budgeting
  • Budgeted amounts available throughout the budget cycle
  • Decisions made through hierarchical committee structure
 

Relationships  
  • Self-organized teams of innovators
  • Innovation enablers that help innovators progress
  • Facilitated through networking and technology
 
  • Assigned and allocated through hierarchy
  • Resides predominantly within organizational silos
  • Requires permission to explore and develop new relationships

Rules  
  • Simple and transparent rules for qualifying and funding innovation
  • Act quickly, very little bureaucracy, enablers can make decisions
  • Freedom to explore semi-permeable boundaries
 
  • Most practices controlled through SOPs and committees
  • Engineer incremental improvements on existing solutions
  • Don’t stray from the core and obtain permission to explore

Roles  
  • Innovation enablers to identify and help promote innovation
  • Doing innovation in your “spare time” based on your passion
  • Leadership promotes tension and enables instability as a core value
 
  • Innovation is assigned primarily to R&D
  • Doing innovation is not your role unless it is assigned to you
  • Leadership limits tensions to maintain stability as a core value

Goals  
  • Get innovation into the organization’s DNA
  • Experience exponential growth by delivering new customer value
  • Constantly improve organizational efficiency
 
  • Predictable and steady growth, no surprises
  • Increase efficiency by eliminating variation through incrementalism
  • Maintain organizational processes and equilibrium